Array
(
[session_started] => 1733968306
[LANGUAGE] => BG
[LEPTON_SESSION] => 1
)
Критерии за рецензиране
-
Suitability of topic
-
Is the topic appropriate for publication in this Journal?
-
Is the topic important to colleagues working in the field?
-
Content
-
How would you rate the novelty of the manuscript?
-
How would you rate the significance of the manuscript?
-
How would you rate the overall organization of the paper?
-
Is the coverage of the topic sufficiently comprehensive and balanced?
-
Are the methods appropriate and presented in sufficient detail?
-
Are the data adequate to support the conclusions?
-
How would you rate the Bibliography?
-
Presentation
-
Writing: Is it clear, concise, and in good English?
-
Title: Is it specific and does it reflect the content of the manuscript?
-
Abstract: Does it indicates the purpose of the work, what was done, what was found, and the significance?
-
Figures: Is the lettering proportionate to the size of the figure? Are there legends?
-
Tables: Can they be simplified or condensed? Should any be omitted?
-
Are symbols, terms, and concepts adequately defined?
-
Template violations
-
Are there violations of the Paper Template?
-
Relative rating of the manuscript
-
Assign a rating of the manuscript relative to other work in the same field
Key: 5=Excellent, 4=Good, 3=Satisfactory, 2=Unsatisfactory, 1=Poor